Blind Tasted and Priced Per 100g: 10 Own-Brand Swaps That Hold Up, 5 Brands That Still Earn It
Nobody wants to be the person who insists the posh ketchup is better without having tested it. So we tested it. Fifteen everyday items, own-label against the big name, tasted without the packaging in sight where we could manage it, and priced per 100g rather than per pack.
This isn't laboratory stuff. It's two people, a kitchen table and a fairly honest scoring sheet. But it's closer to how you actually eat than a marketing claim is, and the results were less tribal than you'd expect. Own-brand won more often than brand loyalty would suggest — and lost in a few places that really matter.
How we judged it
Three things: does it taste close enough that nobody at the table notices, what does it cost per 100g rather than per pack, and does swapping change the dish or just the receipt. A bean that's fine on toast but thin in a chilli is a conditional win, and we've said so.
We compared like with like — standard own-label against standard brand, not the premium own-brand tier, which is a different argument for a different day.
The ten worth switching
1. Baked beans. Own-label standard beans came in at roughly half the price per 100g of the famous blue tin. The sauce is thinner and slightly sweeter, but on toast with cheese nobody clocked it. Switch.
2. Cornflakes and rice cereal. Near-identical in the bowl. The brand version is marginally crisper straight from the box and noticeably less so by day three. Buy the own-label and eat it within a fortnight like a normal person. Switch.
3. Pasta sauce. The biggest gap on the list. Own-label tomato and basil was around £1 for a 500g jar against £2.50-ish for the brand, and tasted fresher — less sugar, more actual tomato. Switch.
4. Dried pasta. Penne is penne. The brand holds its shape a shade better in a bake, which is worth roughly nothing at twice the price. Switch.
5. Tinned tomatoes. Own-label chopped tomatoes were firmer and less watery than the premium brand we tried, at about 60p against £1.30. Switch.
6. Anti-bacterial spray. Same active ingredient, same smell of clean, a third of the price. There is no flavour dimension to lose here. Switch.
7. Biscuits. Custard creams and digestives were indistinguishable in a blind test. The brand's chocolate digestives had a better chocolate-to-biscuit ratio, so buy own-label for the plain ones and treat yourself on the coated. Switch, mostly.
8. Greek-style yoghurt. Thick, tangy, good with honey. The own-label tub was denser than expected and a good £1 cheaper per 500g. Switch.
9. Kitchen roll. Absorbency differences are real but small, and the price difference is not. Switch.
10. Washing-up liquid — with a caveat. Own-label cleans fine. The brand genuinely goes further per squeeze, so the cost per wash is much closer than the shelf price suggests. Switch if you're happy to use a bit more; stick if you're fussy about how long a bottle lasts.
The five where the brand still earns it
Tea. This is the one that ends friendships. Own-label tea bags make a perfectly decent mug when it's strong and milky, but the flavour flattens fast and the second cup is noticeably weaker. Yorkshire Tea and its peers cost more per bag and are worth it if tea is the thing you look forward to.
Ketchup. Own-label versions are too vinegary and too thin. Heinz has the texture and the balance, and a bottle lasts months, so the extra 80p is spread very thin. Stick.
Mayonnaise. Own-label is fine in a sandwich and disappointing on a plate of chips. Real mayo has a richness the cheap stuff can't fake. Stick if you use it as a condiment rather than a binder.
Cola. Blind-tested, and everyone got it wrong in the same direction — the own-brand was identified as 'the cheap one' within a sip. The difference is in the aftertaste. Stick.
Chocolate. Own-label milk chocolate is perfectly edible and slightly waxy. The brand melts better and tastes of more than sugar. This is a small treat, not a staple, so buy the one you actually want.
Where the saving lands
Add up the ten switches on a typical fortnightly shop and you're looking at somewhere between £8 and £14, depending on pack sizes and how much of each you buy. Over a year that's a weekend away, not a life-changing sum — but it's a weekend away you're currently spending on baked beans and kitchen roll.
Three rules to take to the aisle
Compare tiers properly. The value range and the premium own-brand range are not the same product as the standard one, and the middle tier is usually where the honest comparison sits.
Judge the job, not the product. Beans on toast and beans in a stew ask different things of a tin. If a swap makes the meal worse, it isn't a saving.
Try one swap per shop. Nobody changes fifteen habits at once, and a fridge full of unfamiliar versions of things you love is how people give up and go back to paying brand prices out of frustration.
Start with the pasta sauce. It's the easiest win on the list, and it's the one most likely to make you wonder why you hadn't done it sooner.