The £30 Trolley Test: What Aldi, Lidl, Asda and Tesco Really Put in the Basket
Photo: Darrin Antrobus, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
A £30 weekly top-up sounds simple until you are standing in the aisle with a basket that somehow contains three types of cleaning spray and no actual dinner. So this is a basket test with a boring brief: feed a typical UK household for a few days, cover breakfast, dinner basics and cleaning essentials, and spend £30. No loyalty points, no fuel vouchers, no 'spend £50 to save £5' theatre. Just the shelf price and what lands in the trolley.
The basket we priced
We used a representative basket: wheat biscuits, milk, bread, eggs, jam, tea bags, pasta, rice, passata, onions, carrots, potatoes, frozen peas, chopped tomatoes, stock cubes, cooking oil, chicken thighs, washing-up liquid, surface spray, laundry detergent, bin bags and sponges. That is 22 lines, which is enough to be realistic without becoming a full weekly shop.
Prices move constantly in 2026, so treat these as the kind of shelf prices you see in larger stores rather than a locked-in quote. The point is the pattern: what £30 buys, and where the pack sizes start playing games.
Breakfast: £9-ish decides the tone
At Aldi and Lidl, the breakfast run is usually straightforward. Own-brand wheat biscuits, a four-pint milk, a loaf, ten eggs, jam and a box of tea bags tend to land around £8.50 to £9.50 if you stay with own-label. The wins are the staples: milk, eggs and bread are rarely the things that blow the budget.
Asda is competitive on the same list, and it often has more room for brand swaps. The risk is the 'rollback' shelf: a branded cereal at a tempting price can still lose to the own-brand box on price per 100g. Tesco can match the basket, but it is the retailer where the £30 feels tightest unless the Clubcard prices happen to line up with what you already wanted. Since we are ignoring loyalty points, Tesco has to win on the shelf price alone — and on this basket it is a closer run thing.
The pack-size trap here is cereal. A 375g box and a 500g box look similar on the shelf, but the bigger box is not always better value per 100g. Check the unit price before you congratulate yourself.
Dinner basics: £13-ish buys the most at the discounters
This is where Aldi and Lidl tend to pull ahead. Pasta, rice, passata, onions, carrots, potatoes, frozen peas, chopped tomatoes, stock cubes and cooking oil are exactly the kind of everyday lines where the discounters keep things simple. Add chicken thighs and you can still stay near £13 to £14 for the dinner basics.
Asda is the interesting middle ground. It can match the discounters on many own-brand staples, and it gives you more choice if you need a specific size or a brand. But the multibuy displays can inflate the basket. '2 for £3' on pasta sauce is not a win if you only needed one jar and the single jar was already cheap.
Tesco's dinner basics are fine, but the £30 basket starts to feel like a puzzle. The own-brand range is broad, and the prices are often close, but the pack sizes can be less generous. A 500g pasta bag at one retailer and a 500g bag at another are easy to compare; a 300g vs 500g bag of frozen peas is where shoppers get caught.
The biggest stretch here is not a loyalty scheme. It is swapping fresh vegetables for frozen where it makes sense. Frozen peas are a genuine bargain. Bagged carrots and onions are usually cheaper than loose. A whole chicken or chicken thighs can go further than breast fillets for the same money.
Cleaning essentials: £9-ish and the per-wash problem
Cleaning is the section most likely to wreck a £30 basket without anyone noticing. Washing-up liquid, surface spray, laundry detergent, bin bags and sponges can easily add £10 to £12 if you buy the wrong sizes.
Aldi and Lidl are strong here because their own-brand cleaning lines are simple and usually well priced. The catch is that 'big box' laundry detergent is not automatically cheaper. Compare cost per wash, then check the dose. A 30-wash box at £4 is 13p per wash; a 20-wash box at £3.50 is 17.5p per wash. The smaller box can look cheaper on the shelf and lose on the maths.
Asda and Tesco both have frequent cleaning offers, but this is where multibuys multiply. Two surface sprays for £4 is only good if you have two surfaces and a use for both. A refill bottle is often the smarter buy, provided the volume is genuinely larger and the dilution is the same.
Kitchen roll and toilet roll are the classic pack-size illusions. A nine-roll pack can look like a bulk buy until you compare sheets per roll. The same goes for bin bags: check the litre capacity and the count, not just the box size.
Where each retailer wins
Aldi: the most straightforward route to a full £30 basket, especially on dairy, dinner basics and cleaning. Less choice, fewer distractions, and the own-brand staples do the heavy lifting.
Lidl: very similar to Aldi on the core basket, with the weekly offers sometimes adding a useful extra. The risk is the middle aisle: a £30 basket can become a £45 basket if you wander.
Asda: the best of the four for choice at a similar price. It can match the discounters on many lines, but the rollback and multibuy labels need more scrutiny. Good if you need specific sizes or brands.
Tesco: broad range and easy to shop, but the £30 basket is tighter without loyalty prices. It wins on availability and own-brand breadth, not on raw basket generosity.
Swaps that stretch the basket furthest
The biggest wins are not exotic. Buy frozen peas and frozen veg instead of fresh when they will be cooked. Choose a block of cheese and grate it yourself. Buy the larger milk only if you will use it. Pick own-brand cereal, tea and cleaning products. Swap chicken breast for thighs. Use passata or chopped tomatoes instead of jarred pasta sauce. Buy a refill for surface spray if the per-litre price is lower. And check the unit price on every '2 for' offer before you put the second item in the basket.
The honest verdict
A £30 basket in 2026 is still doable for a small household, but it is not equally doable everywhere. Aldi and Lidl make the money go furthest on the basics. Asda gives you more choice for roughly the same spend if you shop carefully. Tesco can do it, but you need to work harder and ignore the loyalty noise. The real winner is not a retailer — it is the shopper who checks the unit price, buys the pack size that fits the household, and refuses to let a multibuy turn a £30 basket into a £40 one.